Cause List 20/12/2007

BEFORE SHRI TALWANT SINGH: PRESIDING OFFICER
DELHI SCHOOL TRIBUNAL DELHI

20/12/2007

Misc. Proceeding (At 10:30 A.M.)


1. 49/2007 Mrs. Jasbir Kaur V/s Guru Nanak Public School & Ors.


2. 05/2007 Sh. Achint Kumar Ganguli V/s Mamta Modern Education Society & Ors.

3. 46/2007 Sh. Achint Kumar Ganguli V/s Mamta Modern Education Society & Ors.

4. 21/2007 Sh. Rakesh Kumar V/s Govt. of N.C.T. of Delhi & Ors.


5. 34/2007 Sh. Rakesh Kumar V/s Govt. of N.C.T. of Delhi & Ors.


6. 39/2007 Sh. Arun Kumar Dhaka V/s Managing Committee Rattan Devi Arya G. S. S. School & Ors.

Final Argument (At 11:30 A.M)


7. 08/1999 Sh. Rakesh Chopra V/s Directorate of Education & Ors.

8. 66/2002 Arwachin Bharti Bhawan Sr. Sec. School & Ors.

9. 28/2005 Smt. Vijoya Chatterjee V/s Guru Angad Public School & Ors.

10. 33/2005 Sh. Samir Chakraborty V/s Raisina Bengali School Society & Ors.

Order (At 4:00 P.M)


11. 20/1998 Mrs. Priti Madan V/s Sumermal Jain Public School & Ors.

12. 04/2001 Ms. Indu Bala V/s Guru Teg Bahadur Public School & Ors.

13. 39/2003 Sh. Kritendra Sharma V/s Directorate of Education & Ors.

14. 47/2003 Ms. Suman Lata V/s Ravindra Memorial Public School & Ors.

15. 46/2003 Ms. Rita Sharma V/s Ravindra Memorial Public School & Ors.

16. 04/2007 Ms. Janet Vinita Jacob V/s Butler Memorial Girls Sr. Sec. School & Ors.

Cause List 19/12/2007

BEFORE SHRI TALWANT SINGH: PRESIDING OFFICER
DELHI SCHOOL TRIBUNAL DELHI

19/12/2007

Misc. Proceeding (At 10:30 A.M.)


1. 10/2007 Ms. Amrita Kumari V/s Directorate of Education & Ors.



Final Argument (At 11:30 A.M)


2. 20/2005 Mrs. Gurdeep Kaur V/s Mother Marry Public School & Ors.

3. 03/2007 Sh. Arshad Mujib Ansari V/s Managing Committee Through Manager Safiq Memorial Sr. Sec. School & Ors.

4. 04/2002 Sh. Jagdish Kumar V/s Amar Public School & Ors. (Six Cases)


Order (At 4:00 P.M)


5. 06/1988 Sh. Ram Nath Sharma V/s Directorate of Education & Ors.
6. 09/2004 Sh. Raj Kumar V/s Directorate of Education & Ors.

7. 30/2003 Sh. Amar Nath V/s Directorate of Education & Ors.

Cause List 18/12/2007

BEFORE SHRI TALWANT SINGH: PRESIDING OFFICER
DELHI SCHOOL TRIBUNAL DELHI

18/12/2007

Misc. Proceeding (At 10:30 A.M.)
1. 44/2007 Smt. Sunita Bugga V/s Directorate of Education & Ors.
2. 01/2007 Sh. Jitendra Sharma V/s Managing Committee & Ors.
3. 19/2006 Mrs. Anita Saini V/s Directorate of Education & Ors.

4. 32/2006 Smt. Kamal Saini V/s Directorate of Education & Ors.
Misc. Argument (At 11:00 A.M)

5. 04/2003 Smt. Sunita V/s Indira Ideal Sr. Sec. School & Ors.

6. 18/2006 Mrs. Bimla Gupta V/s St. Mary’s School & Ors.


Final Argument (At 11:30 A.M)

7. 21/2000 Ms. Usha Chawla V/s St. Mary’s Sr. Sec. School & Ors.

8. 40/2001 Mrs. Vinita Vashishth V/s Manav Sthali School & Ors.

9. 56/2002 Mrs. Renu Gupta V/s Dayanand Model Sr. Sec. School & Ors.
10. 05/2003 Mrs. Shayamashri Majumdar V/s Remal Public Sr. Sec. School & Ors.

11. 07/2003 Tapti Mitra V/s Sh. Santan Dharam Plublic School & Ors.

12. 29/2005 Ms. Shampa Ganguly V/s Mamta Modern Sr. Sec. School & Ors.

13. 35/2005 Sh. Baldev Singh V/s Delhi Public School & Ors.


Order (At 4:00 P.M)

14. 04/2000 Smt. Maheshwari V/s D.A.V. College Management Committee & Ors.

15. 17/2006 Bhudev Parsad V/s Cambridge Primary School & Ors.

16. 22/2006 Ms. Ameeta Singhal V/s Managing Committee Holy Child Auxilium School & Ors.

17. 15/1997 Sh. Chatter Singh V/s Apeejay School & Ors.

Cause List 17/12/2007

BEFORE SHRI TALWANT SINGH: PRESIDING OFFICER
DELHI SCHOOL TRIBUNAL DELHI

17/12/2007

Misc. Proceeding (At 10:30 A.M.)

1. 21/2006 Sh. Rajinder Goyal V/s Hansraj Model School & Ors.

2. 40/2007 Sh. Bansi Lal V/s Cambridge Foundation Sr. Sec. School & Ors.

3. 41/2007 Sh. Ram Kalap Tiwari V/s Cambridge Foundation Sr. Sec. School & Ors.

4. 18/2004 Ms. Shashi Chawla V/s S.M. Arya Public School & Ors.


Final Argument (At 11:30 A.M)

5. 20/1998 Mrs. Priti Mdan V/s Sumermal Jain Public School & Ors.

6. 37/1998 Sh. Faqir Chand V/s Samarth Shiksha Mandir

7. 38/1998 Sh. Vishwanath V/s Samarth Shiksha Mandir

8. 19/2001 Mrs. Mithilesh Mishra V/s Spring Meadows Public School & Ors.
9. 24/2005 Mrs.Manisha Sood V/s Bal Bharti Public School & Ors.

10. 11/2006 Mrs. Anupama Arora V/s Directorate Of Education & Ors.


Order (At 4:00 A.M)


11. 07/2005 Sh. Suresh Chandra Kalra V/s Apeejay School & Ors.

12. 16/2007 Sh. Mitender Sharma V/s Cambridge Foundation Sr. Sec. School & Ors.

13. 17/2007 Sh. Ram Pakat V/s Cambridge Foundation Sr. Sec. School & Ors.

Cause Lise 14/12/2004

BEFORE SHRI TALWANT SINGH: PRESIDING OFFICER
DELHI SCHOOL TRIBUNAL DELHI

14/12/2007

Misc. Proceeding (At 10:30 A.M.)

1. 37/1997 Sh. Surender Rana V/s D.A.V.Centenary Public School & Ors.

2. 35/2007 Ms. Preeti Sodhi V/s Apeejay School & Ors.


3. 25/2007 Smt. Mridul Sharma V/s Directorate of Education & Ors.


4. 20/2003 Mrs. Seema V/s The Managing Committee S.D. Public School & Ors.

5. 31/2004 Sh. Anupam Kashyap V/s S.D. Public School & Ors.

Misc. Argument (At 11:00 A.M)

6. 15/2004 Mrs. Dimple Gupta V/s Suraj Kanya Shikshalaya & Ors.

7. 39/2003 Sh. Kritendra Sharma V/s Directorate of Education & Ors.

8. 17/2002 Sh. Raj Kumar V/s Delhi Jain Public School & Ors. (Foure Cases)
Final Argument (At 11:30 A.M)


9. 12/2001 Sh. A.A. Vetal V/s The Managing Committee Saraswati Bal Mandir & Ors.

10. 43/2003 Sh. Bhushan Tripathi V/s Samarath Siksha Samiti & Ors.


11. 33/2002 Mrs. Manisha Kochar V/s University of Delhi & Ors.


12. 36/2002 Mrs. Varinder Goswami V/s D.A.V. College Managing Committee & Ors.

13. 34/2004 Sh. Raghubir Singh V/s Hope Hall Foundation School & Ors.


14. 26/2006 Mrs. Shobha Arvind Dhingra V/s D.A.V. College Management Committee & Ors.

Order (At 4:00 A.M)

15. 17/2004 Mrs. Khima Devi V/s Ravindra Memorial Public School & Ors.
16. 11/2005 Mrs. Rani Tiwari V/s Guru Tegh Bahadur Public School & Ors.

Cause List 13/12/2007

BEFORE SHRI TALWANT SINGH: PRESIDING OFFICER
DELHI SCHOOL TRIBUNAL DELHI

13/12/2007

Misc. Proceeding (At 10:30 A.M.)


1. 31/2006 Ms Renu Malhotra V/s Happy Model School & Ors.

2. 08/2007 Mrs. Soma Pani Chattopadhyay V/s Hamdard Public School & Ors.

3. 14/2001 Sh. Mahender Kumar Vatsa V/s Birla Vidya Niketan & Ors.

Misc. Argument (At 11:00 A.M)

4. 33/2007 Ms. Kusum Lata V/s N.C.T. of Delhi & Ors.


5. 37/2007 Sh. Sukhdev Jain V/s Modern School & Ors.


6. 15/1997 Sh. Chatter Singh V/s Apeejay School & Ors.


7. 01/2005 Mrs. Madhu Sharma V/s Bal Bhawan Public School & Ors. (Five Cases)

Final Argument (At 11:30 A.M)


8. 31/1997 Sh. Rakesh Kumar Chauhan V/s The Managing Committee Bharat National Public School & Ors.(Two Cases)

9. 15/1998 Sh. Dinesh Singh V/s The Management Ryan International School & Ors.


10 35/1998 Sh. Ashok Shastri V/s S.M. Arya Public School & Ors.


11. 10/2004 Sh. Sonesh Kumar Sharma V/s Himalaya Public Sr. Sec. School & Ors.


12. 26/2007 Sh. Ganesh V/s Appex Public School & Ors.


Order (At 4:00 A.M)

13. 22/1999 Sh. M.K. Aggarwal V/s Sadhu Vaswani International School & Ors.

14. 04/2007 Ms. Janet Vinita Jacob V/s Butler Memorial Girls Sr. Sec. School & Ors.

Cause List For 12-12-2007

BEFORE SHRI TALWANT SINGH: PRESIDING OFFICER
DELHI SCHOOL TRIBUNAL DELHI

Misc. Proceeding (At 10:30 A.M.)


1. 44/2007 Mrs. Sunita Bugga V/s Director of Education & Ors.

2. 27/2007 Dr. Santosh Sharma V/s Director of Education & Ors.

Final Argument (At 11:30 A.M)

3. 08/2001 Dr R P Das V/s Gyan Bharti School & Ors.

4. 60/2002 Sh. Hari Om Sharma V/s Kulachi Hansraj Model School & Ors.

5. 04/2004 Ms. Amita Dara V/s Kathuria Public School & Ors.

6. 39/2005 Sh. Manoj Kumar V/s Gur Harkishan Public School & Ors.

7. 15/2007 Mrs Kiran Bala Sharma V/s Lott Carey Baptist Mission in India (Regd) & Ors.

Order (At 4:00 A.M)


9. 07/2005 Sh. Suresh Chandra Kalra V/s Apeejay School & Ors.

10. 24/2007 Smt Ravinder Kaur Datta V/s Guru Nanak Public School & Ors.

Cause List 11/12/2007

BEFORE SHRI TALWANT SINGH: PRESIDING OFFICER
DELHI SCHOOL TRIBUNAL DELHI

11/12/2007

Misc. Proceeding (At 10:30 A.M.)


1. 47/2005 Ms. Sunita Parashar V/s DAV Public School & Ors.

2. 11/2004 Mrs. Meera Dimri V/s Management Neo-Convent Sr. Sec. School & Ors.

Misc. Argument (At11:00 A.M)

3. 03/1991 Mrs.Usha Rani V/s Directorate of Education & Ors.

4. 09/2005 Sh. Rajender Kumar Gupta V/s Directorate of Education & Ors.

Final Argument (At 11:30 A.M)


5. 12/1994 Ms. Santosh Sharma V/s Managing Committee Guru Nanak Public School & Ors.

6. 25/2000 Sh. Anirudh Kumar Panday V/s M/S Modern Public School & Ors.

7. 24/2002 Sh. Kailash Chand V/s Goodley Public School & Ors.


8. 45/2003 Sh. Dipak Chandra V/s M/S Savti Devi Memorial Sr. Sec. Vidya Mandir & Ors.

9. 22/2004 Mrs. Veena Sharma V/s The Management of Air Force Golden Jublee Institute & Ors.


Order (At 4:00 A.M)


10. 34/1991 Sh. Anand Swaroop Mittal V/s Ramjas Sr. Sec. School & Ors.

11. 04/2000 Smt.Maheshwari V/s D.A.V. College Management Committee & Ors.

Cause List 10/12/2007

BEFORE SHRI TALWANT SINGH: PRESIDING OFFICER
DELHI SCHOOL TRIBUNAL DELHI

10/12/2007

Misc. Proceeding (At 10:30 A.M.)


1. 38/2007 Smt. Grupiari V/s Sh. Vansthali Public School & Ors.


Misc. Argument (At11:00 A.M)


2. 06/1998 Sh. Ram Nath Sharma V/s Directorate of Education & Ors.

Final Argument (At 11:30 A.M)

3. 19/1997 Sh. C.L. Sethi V/s Directorate of Education & Ors.


4. 23/1999 Smt. Raj Rani V/s Vanasthali Public School & Ors.


5. 08/2005 Sh. Sudesh Kumar Sharma V/s Gyan Bharti School & Ors.

6. 16/2006 Sh. Virender Verma V/s Vivekanand Shiksha Samiti & Ors.

7. 20/2006 Sh. Lalit Mohan Gupta V/s Management Committee Vivekanand Shiksha Smiti & Ors.

8. 03/2007 Sh. Arshad Mujib Ansari V/s Managing Committee Shafi Memorial Sr. Sec. School & Ors.

Order (At 4:00 A.M)


9. 18/1996 Sh. D.N. Kumar V/s Directorate of Education & Ors.

10 04/2001 Ms. Indu Bala V/s Guru Teg Bahadur Public School & Ors.

Cause List 07/12/2007

BEFORE SHRI TALWANT SINGH: PRESIDING OFFICER
DELHI SCHOOL TRIBUNAL DELHI

07/12/2007


Final Arguments (At 11:30 A.M.)

1. 12/2002 Sh Paras Nath Sharma V/s Delhi Public School & Ors.
2. 01/2002 Sh. Bir Singh Delhi Public School & Ors.(Two Cases)

3. 17/2002 Sh. Raj Kumar V/s Delhi Jain Public School & Ors.(Four Cases)
4. 22/2003 Sh. Ramu V/s Tha Management Bengal Education & Ors.
5. 23/2003 Mrs. Sheela V/s The Management Bengal Education & Ors.
6. 14/2005 Mrs. Anita Bhandari V/s D.E. & Ors.(Three Cases)

7. 21/2005 Mrs. Kanwaljit Kaur V/s Sahibzada Ajit Singh public School (Three Cases)


Order (At 4:00 P.M)
8. 41/1997 Mrs. Neena Thomas V/s St.

Cause list 06/12/2007

BEFORE SHRI TALWANT SINGH: PRESIDING OFFICER
DELHI SCHOOL TRIBUNAL DELHI

06/12/2007


Misc. Proceedings (At 10:30 A.M.)


1. 11/2007 Ms.Seema Tiwari V/s Preet Public Sr. Sec. School & Ors.


Misc. Arguments (11.00 A.M)


2. 39/2003 Sh. Kritendra Sharma V/s Directorate of Education & Ors

3. 17/2004 Mrs. Khima Devi V/s Ravindra Memorial Public School & Ors.


Final Arguments (At 11:30 A.M.)


4. 25/1994 Mrs. Veena Joshi V/s S.D. Public School & Ors.


5. 23/2001 Mrs. Neeru Jaggi V/s Francis Girls Sr. Sec. School & Ors.

6. 46/2003 Ms.Rita Sharma V/s Ravindra Memorial Plublic Schoo & Ors.

7. 47/2003 Ms. Suman Lata V/s Ravindra Memorial Plublic Schoo & Ors.

8. 10/2001 Ms. Sangeeta Monga V/s M/S. Goodley Public School & Ors.


Order (At 4:00 P.M)


9. 17/2004 Mrs. Khima Devi V/s Ravindra Memorial Public School & Ors.

Cause Liste 05/12/2007

BEFORE SHRI TALWANT SINGH : PRESIDING OFFICER
DELHI SCHOOL TRIBUNAL : DELHI

CAUSE LIST FOR: 05/12/2007


Misc. Proceeding (10.30 A.M.)

1. 27/2006 Mrs. Shikha Chaudhari Srivastava V/s The Managing Committee Joseph & Mary School & Ors.

Misc. Arguments (11:00 A.M.)

2. 15/2004 Mrs. Dimple Gupta V/s Suraj Kanya Shikshalaya & Ors.

3. 17/2006 Bhudev Parsad V/s Cambridge Primary School & Ors.

Final Argument (At 11.30 A.M.)

4. 21/2003 Suman Abbi V/s Maharaja Agrasen Model School & Ors.

5. 33/2003 Mrs. Sangeet Sharma V/s D.A.V. Centenary Public School & Ors.

6. 30/2003 Sh. Amar Nath V/s Directorate of Education & Ors.

7. 09/2004 Sh. Raj Kumar V/s Directorate of Education & Ors.

8. 06/2004 Mrs. Ajay Kiran Sharma V/s Academy for Education & Culture
Society & Ors.

9. 32/2004 Sh. N.K. Sharma V/s Directorate of Education & Ors.


Order (At. 4.00 P.M)


10 09/1999 Smt. Anjana Samnol V/s Directorate of Education & Ors.11

11 21/2004 Sh. Mohan Lal Saran V/s Directorate of Education & Ors.

CAUSE LIST OF 04/12/2007

BEFORE SHRI TALWANT SINGH: PRESIDING OFFICER

DELHI SCHOOL TRIBUNAL DELHI

Misc. Proceeding (10.30 A.M.)

1. 40/2007 Sh. Bansi Lal V/s Cambridge Foundation Sr. Sec. School & Ors.

2. 41/2007 Sh. Ram Kalap Tiwari V/s Cambridge Foundation Sr. Sec. School & Ors.

Misc. Arguments (11:00 A.M.)

3. 22/2006 Ms. Ameeta Singhal V/s Managing Committee, Holy Child Auxilium School

4. 06/2006 Mrs. Amita Suman V/s Management of S.S. Mota Singh Model School & Ors.

Final Argument (11.30 A.M.)

5. 14/2003 Mrs. Shubni Jalali V/s Director of Education & Ors.

6. 16/2003 Ms. Amita Goel V/s Himalaya Public Sr. Sec. School & Ors.

7. 15/2003 Ms. Sucheta Katyal V/s Himalaya Public Sr. Sec. School & Ors.

8. 23/2004 Chloris Cleetus V/s Managing Committee Loreto Convent School & Ors.

9. 31/2005 Sh. Ajay Singh V/s Delhi Police Public School & Ors.

10. 03/2007 Sh. Arshad Mujib Ansari V/s Managing Committee Safi Memorial Sr. Sec. School & Ors.

Order ( 4.00 P.M.)

11. 37/2002 Sh. Radhey Shyam Sharma V/s Chunni Lal Saraswati Bal Mandir & Ors.

12. 12/2004 Sh. Vinod Kumar V/s Principal, S. Jassa Singh Ramgarhia Public School & Ors.

Cause List 03-12-2007

BEFORE SHRI TALWANT SINGH: PRESIDING OFFICER
DELHI SCHOOL TRIBUNAL DELHI
03/12/2007



Misc. Proceedings (At 10:30 A.M.)


1. 36/2007 Ms. Naorem Sheilani V/s Radhakrishan International School & Ors.

2. 47/2007 Smt. Pooja Kapoor V/s The Managing Committee Saviour Convent Sr. Sec. School & Ors.

3. 30/2006 Mr. Hemant Kumar V/s The Managing Committee Hindon Public Sec. School & Ors.


Final Arguments (At 11:30 A.M.)

4. 13/1996: Mrs. Meena Sanghi V/s Rukmini Devi Public Schopol & Ors.

5. 24/1999: Mrs. Harbhajan Kaur V/s The Managing Committee, Jain Happy School & Ors.

6. 32/2000: Ms. Anita V/s St. Martin’s School & Ors.

7. 16/2004 Mrs. Madhu Kakaria V/s Champa Devi Aggarwal Saraswati Bal Mandir & Ors.

8. 40/2005 Smt. Deepshikha Saxena V/s Shiksha Bharti Sr. Sec. Public School & Ors. (Five Cases)

9. 05/2006 Mrs. Rekha Shanker V/s Directorate of Education & Ors.

CAUSE LIST OF 30/11/2007

BEFORE SHRI TALWANT SINGH: PRESIDING OFFICER
DELHI SCHOOL TRIBUNAL DELHI


Misc. Proceedings (At 10:30 A.M.)

1. 10/2007 Ms. Amrita Kumari V/s Directorate of Education & Ors.

2. 41/2007 Sh. Ashok Kumar (Five Cases) V/s S.M. Arya Public School & Ors.

Final. Arguments (At 11:30 A.M.)

3. 05/1999 Sh. Mahinder Kumar Sharma V/s The Management of Green Field School & Ors.

4. 13/2002 Sh. Shiv Kumar Sharma V/s St. Columbas School & Ors.

5. 38/2001 Sh. S.P. Sharma V/s Managing Committee St. Lawrence Convent School & Ors.

6. 09/2001 Ms. Neena Arora V/s Directorate of Education & Ors.

7. 42/2003 Mrs. Prachi Gupta V/s Green Fields School & Ors.

8. 41/2003 Ms. Neera Chopra V/s Naval Public School & Ors.

9. 30/2004 Sh. Ramesh Chand V/s Gyan Sagar Public School & Ors.

10. 34/2004 Sh. Raghubir Singh V/s Hope Hall Foundation School & Ors.

11. 27/2005 Mrs. Archana Saini V/s Air Force Senior Secondary School & Ors.

Order (At 04:00P.M.)

12. 41/1997 Mrs. Neena Thomes V/s St. Columbas School & Ors.

13. 04/2001 Ms. Indu Bala V/s Guru Teg Bahadur Public School & Ors.

14. 04/2000 Smt. Maheshwari V/s D.A.V.College Management Committee & Ors.

15. 07/2005 Sh. Suresh Chandra Kalra V/s Apeejay School & Ors.

16. 04/2007 Ms. Janet Vinita Jacob V/s Butler Memorial Girls Sr. Sec. School & Ors.

17. 16/2007 Sh. Mitender Sharma V/s Cambridge Foundation Sr. Sec.School & Ors.

18 17/2007 Sh. Ram Pakat V/s Cambridge Foundation Sr. Sec. School & Ors.

Cause List 29/11/2007

BEFORE SHRI TALWANT SINGH: PRESIDING OFFICER
DELHI SCHOOL TRIBUNAL DELHI

29/11/2007

Misc. Proceedings (At 10:30 A.M.)

1. 23/2007 : Sh. Ramji Lal V/s Ganga Happy Public School & Ors.

2. 30/2007 : Sh. Jai Charan V/s Don Bosco School & Ors.

3. 31/2007 Sh. Jai Charan V/s Don Bosco School & Ors.

4. 12/2007 Sh Ranjit Roy V/s Delhi Public School & Ors.

5. 36/2005 Ms. Rajni Hasija V/s Delhi Public School & Ors.

Final. Arguments (At 11:30 A.M.)

6. 02/2001 : Smt. Shashi Bala V/s Sardar Patel Public Sr. Sec. School & Ors.
7. 24/2001 Sh. Vinod Kumar V/s D.A.V. Public School & Ors.

8. 36/2001 Sh. Bal Bahadur Thapa V/s D.A.V College Managing Committee & Ors.
9. 05/2003 Sh. Abdul Rehman V/s Birla Sports Centre & Ors.

10. 19/2005 Sh. Dhanpat Singh V/s Directorate of Education & Ors.

11. 28/2006 Ms. Deepa Chhibber V/s Dayanad Adarsh Vidyalaya & Ors.

12. 07/2007 Sh. Himanshu Pande V/s Managing Committee of Banyan Tree(for Merly Rai School) & Ors.

Order (At 04:00P.M.)

13. 27/1997 : Smt. Lata Sharma V/s The Manager, J.S.S.Khalsa School & Ors.

14. 22/1999 : Sh. M.K. Aggarwal V/s Sadhu Vaswani International School & Ors.

15. 11/2005 Mrs. Rani Tiwari V/s Guru Tegh Bahadur Public School & Ors.

Cause List 28/11/2007

BEFORE SHRI TALWANT SINGH: PRESIDING OFFICER
DELHI SCHOOL TRIBUNAL DELHI

CAUSE LIST DATED 28/11/2007

Misc. Proceeding (10.30 A.M.)

1. 12/2005 Sh. Chander Pal V/s Harcourt Butler Sr. Sec. School.& Ors.

2. 43/2007 Sh. Sain Singh & Others V/s Harcourt Butler Sr. Sec. School & Ors.

3. 19/2006 Mrs. Anita Saini V/s Directorate of Education & Ors.

4. 32/2006 Smt. Kamal Saini V/s Directorate of Education & Ors.

Misc. Arguments (At 11:00 A.M.)

5. 17/2004 Mrs. Khima Devi V/s Ravindra Memorial Public School & Ors.

Final Arguments (At 11:30 A.M.)


6. 19/1988 Sh. K.L. Malhotra V/s Directorate of Education & Ors.

7. 21/1998 Sh. Om Prakash Arora V/s Managing Committee Mira Model Sr. Sec. School & Ors.

8. 29/1998 Sh. Inderbir Singh V/s The Management of Goodley Public School & Ors.

9. 6/2001 Sh. Suresh Chandara V/s Rukmani Devi Jaipuria Public School & Ors.

10. 15/2000 Sh. Kushal Singh V/s Mont Fort Sr. Sec. School & Ors.

11. 19/2003 Smt. Sangeeta Thapar V/s Directorate of Education & Ors.


Orders (At 4.00 P.M.)


12. 34/1991 Sh. Anand Swaroop Mittal V/s Ramjas Sr. Sec. School & Ors.

13. 4/2007 Ms. Janet Vinita Jacob V/s Butler Memorial Girls Sr. Sec. School & Ors.

14. 24/2007 Smt. Ravinder Kaur Datta V/s Guru Nank Public School & Ors.

Cause List 27-11-2007

BEFORE SHRI TALWANT SINGH: PRESIDING OFFICER
DELHI SCHOOL TRIBUNAL DELHI

CAUSE LIST DATED 27/11/2007

Misc. Proceeding (10.30 A.M.)

1. 21/2006 Sh. Rajinder Goyal V/s Hansraj Model School & Ors.

2. 06/2007 Smt. Vatsala Pathak V/s The Manager M.M. Public School & Ors.

Final Argument (At 11.30 A.M.)

3. 15/1999 Smt. Poonam Vig. V/s Sadhu Vaswani International School & Ors.

4. 15/2001 Smt. Ranju Mangon V/s Nutan Vidhya Mandir & Ors.

5. 22/2001 Smt. Surekah Rani V/s Mukta Bharti Middle Public School & Ors.

6. 4/2004 Ms Amita Dara V/s Kathuria Public School & Ors.

7. 7/2005 Sh. Suresh Chandra Kalra V/s Apeejay School & Ors.

8. 26/2007 Sh. Ganesh V/s Apex Public School & Ors.

9. 29/2007 Sh. Vinod Kumar Matta V/s Modern Public School & Ors.

Order ( At 4.00 P.M.)

10. 4/2001 Ms Indu Bala V/s Guru Teg Bahadur Public School & 007AOrs.

CAUSE LIST OF 26/11/2007

BEFORE SHRI TALWANT SINGH: PRESIDING OFFICER
DELHI SCHOOL TRIBUNAL DELHI



Misc. Proceeding (10.30 A.M.)

1. 37/2003 Mrs Shweta Mehta V/s Bhartiya Vidya Bhawan & Ors.

Misc. Argument (At 11.00 A.M.)


2. 44/2007 Ms. Sunita Bugga V/s Director of Education & Ors.

3. 09/199 Smt. Anjana Samnol V/s Director of Education & Ors.

Final Argument (At 11.30 A.M.)

4. 09/1997 Sh Deva Nand & Ors (6 Cases) V/s Krishna Model School & Ors.

5. 01/2000 Smt. Shashi Gaur V/s Director of Education & Ors.

6. 24/2000 Smt. Niranjan Sharma V/s National Victor Public School & Ors.

7. 64/2002 Sh. Gajraj Singh V/s D A V Centernary Public School & Ors.

8. 25/2006 Smt Sushma Tandon V/s St Sophia’s Sr. Sec School & Ors.

9. 07/2006 Mrs Savinder Verma V/s Doon Public School & Ors


Order ( At 4.00 P.M.)

10 34/1994 Sh. Chander Parkash GautamV/s Ramjas Sr Sec School & Ors.

CAUSE LIST OF 23/11/2007

BEFORE SHRI TALWANT SINGH: PRESIDING OFFICER
DELHI SCHOOL TRIBUNAL DELHI

Misc. Proceeding (10.30 A.M.)

1. 05/2007 Sh. Achint Kumar Ganguli V/s The Mamta Modern Education Scociety & Ors.

2. 46/2007 Sh. Achint Kumar Ganguli V/s The Mamta Modern Education Society & Ors.

3. 01/2007 Sh. Jitendra Sharma V/s Managing Committee Geeta Bal Bharti Sr. Sec. School & Ors.

4. 40/2003 Ms Indira Sharma V/s Heera Public School & Ors.

5. 39/2001 Sh. Balbir Singh V/s The Management of Bosco Sr. Sec. Public School & Ors.

Misc. Argument (At 11.00 A.M.)

6. 1/2005 Ms. Madhu Sharma V/s Bal Bhawan Public School & Ors.

7. 2/2005 Smt. Renu Malthora V/s Bal Bhawan Public School & Ors.

8. 3/2005 Smt.. Madhu Malhotra V/s Bal Bhawan Public School & Ors.

9. 4/2005 Smt. Saneh Lata V/s Bal Bhawan Public School & Ors.

10. 05/2005 Smt. Meena V/s Bal Bhawan Public School & Ors.

Final Argument (At 11.30 A.M.)

11. 22/2000 Smt. Surender V/s Dr. Swami Rampal Singh Mission School & Ors.

12. 35/2004 Smt. Denny Thomas V/s Director of Education & Ors.

13. 26/2005 Smt. Monika Jawa V/s Maharaja Agrasen Model School & Ors.

14. 16/2007 Sh. Mitender Sharma V/s Cambridge Foundation Sr. Sec. School & Ors.

15. 17/2007 Sh. Ram Pakat V/s Cambridge Foundation Sr. Sec. School & Ors.

Order ( At 4.00 P.M.)

16 21/2004 Sh. Mohan Lal Saran V/s Govt. of NCT of Delhi & Ors.

CAUSE LIST OF 22/11/2007

BEFORE SHRI TALWANT SINGH: PRESIDING OFFICER
DELHI SCHOOL TRIBUNAL DELHI


Misc. Proceeding (10.30 A.M.)

1. 18/2007 Ms. Bharti Shaunik V/s Director of Education & ors.

2. 19/2007 Smt. Rashi Sekhri V/s The Director of Education & Ors.

3. 20/2007 Sh. S.D. Sharma V/s Director of Education & Ors.

4. 11/2007 Ms Seema Tiwari V/s Preet Public Sr. Sec. School & ors.

5. 39/2001 Sh. Balbir Singh V/s The Management of Bosco Sr. Sec. Public & Ors.

Final Argument (At 11.30 A.M.)


6. 19/1996 Sh. D.N. Kumar V/s Director of Education & Ors.

7. 27/1998 Sh. Ravinder Jain V/s The Managing Committee, Ramjas School & Ors.

8. 02/2004 Mrs. Rajwanti V/s Ms Lady Irwin Sr. Sec. School & Ors.

9. 11/2005 Mrs. Rani Tiwari V/s Guru Teg Bahadur Public School & Ors.

Order ( At 4.00 P.M.)

10. 33/2004 Mrs. Usha Sahi V/s The Management of Sophia Sr. Sec. School & Ors.

11. 04/2007 Ms. Janet Vinita Jacob V/s Butler Memorial Girls Sr. Sec. School & Ors.

Caus List 21-11-2007

BEFORE SHRI TALWANT SINGH: PRESIDING OFFICER
DELHI SCHOOL TRIBUNAL DELHI

CAUSE LIST DATED 21/11/2007

Misc. Proceeding (10.30 A.M.)


1. 47/2005 Ms. Sunita Prashar V/s D.A.V Public School & Ors.

2. 32/2007 Smt. Sunder Kumari @ Sumita V/s Managing Committee, Maharaja Agrasain Public School & Ors.

3. 11/2004 Smt. Meera Dimri V/s The Management, NEO Convent Sr. Sec. School & Ors.


Final Argument (At 11.30 A.M.)

4. 23/1998 Sh. Rakesh Sinha V/s Malviya Public School & Ors.

5. 04/1999 Sh. Brijesh Kumar V/s Director of Education & Ors.

6. 22/2002 Smt. Sunita Rana V/s Vidya Jyoti Public School & Ors.

7. 23/2002 Smt. Saroj Bala V/s Vidya Jyoti Public School & Ors.

8. 13/2003 Smt. Rekha Sharma V/s D.A.V. Cen. Public School.

9. 1/2006 Smt. Trivender Kaur V/s Bhai Lalo Public School & Ors.
10. 33/ 2006 Sh. Rajesh Khullar V/s Director of Education & Ors.


Order ( At 4.00 P.M.)

11. 37/2002 Sh. Radhey Shyam Sharma V/s Chunni Lal Sarswati Bal Mandir & Ors.

12. 12/2004 Sh. Vinod Kumar V/s Principal S. Jassa Singh Ramgarhia Public School & Ors.

Cause List 20-11-2007

Misc. Argument (11.00 A.M)

1. 18/2006 Mrs. Bimla Gupta V/s St. Marys’ School & Ors.

Final Argument (At 11.30 A.M.)


2. 24/2003 Sh. Satya Narayan V/S MDH International School & Ors.

3. 26/2004 Sh. Raj Kumar V/s Dte. of Education & Ors.

4. 27/2004 Sh. Pardeep Kumar V/s Director of Education & Ors.

5. 12/2001 Ms. Manju Sikka V/s Mount Abu Sr. Sec. School & O rs.

6. 46/2005 Ms. Anshu Sharma V/s Director of Education & Ors.

Order ( At 4.00 P.M.)

7. 27/1997 Smt. Lalta Sharma V/s The Manager J.S.S Khalsa School & Ors.

CAUSE LIST OF 19/11/2007

BEFORE SHRI TALWANT SINGH: PRESIDING OFFICER
DELHI SCHOOL TRIBUNAL DELHI



Misc. Proceedings (10.30 A.M)

1. 29/2004 Ms. Anuradha Dravid V/s Sri Ram School & Ors.


Final Argument (At 11.30 A.M.)


2. 34/1991 Sh. Anand Swaroop Mittal V/s Ramjas Sr. Sec. School & Ors.

3, 04/2001 Smt. Maheshwari V/s D.A.V. College Management Committee & Ors.

4. 12/2006 Ms. Dharamviri Devi V/s Vijay Jyoti Co-Ed. Middle School & Ors.

5. 26/2006 Mrs. Shobha Arvind Dhingra V/s D.A.V. College Management Committee & Ors.


Order ( At 4.00 P.M.)

6. 41/1997 Mrs. Neena Thomas V/s St. Columbas School & Ors.

7. 37/2002 Sh. Radhey Shyam Sharma V/s Chunni Lal Saraswati Bal Mandir & Ors.

Cause List 16-11-2007

BEFORE SHRI TALWANT SINGH: PRESIDING OFFICER
DELHI SCHOOL TRIBUNAL DELHI


CAUSE LIST DATED 16/11/2007


Misc. Proceedings (10.30 A.M)

1. 05/2007 Sh. Achint Kumar Ganguli V/s The Mamta Modern Education Society & Ors.

2. 46/2007 Sh. Achint Kumar Ganguli V/s The Mamta Modern Education Society & Ors.

3. 25/2007 Smt. Mridul Sharma V/s Director of Education & Ors.


Misc. Arguments (At 11:00 A.M.)


4. 06/1988 Sh. Ram Nath Sharma V/s Director of Education.


5. 04/2003 Ms. Sunita V/s Indira Idel Sr. Sec. School & Ors.


Final Argument (At 11.30 A.M.)


6. 28/2000 Mrs. Kanika Sarkar V/s Bidhan Chandra Vidyalaya & Ors.

7. 09/2003 Sh. Jyoti Verma V/s Bal Bharti Public School & Ors.


8. 35/2003 Ms. Rashmi Dubey V/s Geeta Bal Bharti, Sr. Sec. School & Ors.

9. 20/2003 Mrs. Seema V/s The Managing Committee, S.D. Public School & Ors.

10. 31/2004 Sh. Anupam Kashyap V/s S.D. Public School & Ors.


Order ( At 4.00 P.M.)

11. 22/ 1999 Sh. M.K. Aggarwal V/s Sadhu Vaswani International School &: Ors.

12. 24/2007 Smt. Ravinder Kaur Datta V/s Guru Nanak Public School & Ors.

Cause List 15-11-2007

BEFORE SHRI TALWANT SINGH: PRESIDING OFFICER
DELHI SCHOOL TRIBUNAL DELHI

15/11/2007


Misc. Proceedings (10.30 A.M)

1. 31/2006 Ms Renu Malhotra V/s Happy Model School & Ors.


Misc. Arguments (At 11:00 A.M.)

2. 1/2005 Ms. Madhu Sharma V/s Bal Bhawan Public School & Ors.

3. 03/2005 Ms Madhu Malhotra V/s Bal Bhawan Public School &
Ors.

4. 02/2005 Ms Renu Malhotra & Ors. V/s Bal Bhawan Public
School.

5. 04/2005 Mrs. Saneh Lata V/s Bal Bhawan Public School & Ors.

6 05/2005 Ms. Meena V/s Bal Bhawan Public School & Ors.


Final Argument (At 11.30 A.M.)


7. 19/1998 Sh. K.L. Malhotra V/s Director of Education & Ors.


8. 1/2004 Sh. Sandeep Singh V/s Kulachi Hansraj Model School & Ors.

9. 26/2006 Mrs. Shobha Arvind Dhingra V/s D.A.V College Management Committee & Ors.

Cause List 15-11-2007

BEFORE SHRI TALWANT SINGH: PRESIDING OFFICER
DELHI SCHOOL TRIBUNAL DELHI

15/11/2007


Misc. Proceedings (10.30 A.M)

1. 31/2006 Ms Renu Malhotra V/s Happy Model School & Ors.


Misc. Arguments (At 11:00 A.M.)

2. 1/2005 Ms. Madhu Sharma V/s Bal Bhawan Public School & Ors.

3. 03/2005 Ms Madhu Malhotra V/s Bal Bhawan Public School &
Ors.

4. 02/2005 Ms Renu Malhotra & Ors. V/s Bal Bhawan Public
School.

5. 04/2005 Mrs. Saneh Lata V/s Bal Bhawan Public School & Ors.

6 05/2005 Ms. Meena V/s Bal Bhawan Public School & Ors.


Final Argument (At 11.30 A.M.)


7. 19/1998 Sh. K.L. Malhotra V/s Director of Education & Ors.


8. 1/2004 Sh. Sandeep Singh V/s Kulachi Hansraj Model School & Ors.

9. 26/2006 Mrs. Shobha Arvind Dhingra V/s D.A.V College Management Committee & Ors.

Cause List of 14/11/2007

BEFORE SHRI TALWANT SINGH: PRESIDING OFFICER
DELHI SCHOOL TRIBUNAL DELHI

14/11/2007


Misc. Proceedings (10.30 A.M)

1. 08/2007 Mrs. Soma Pani Chattopadhyay V/s Hamdard Public School & Ors.

2. 15/1997 Sh. Chatter Singh V/s Apeejay School & Ors.

3. 09/2005 Sh. Rajinder Kumar Gupta V/s Director of Education & Ors.

4. 03/2007 Sh. Arshad Mujib Ansari V/s Managing Committee Shafi Memorial Sec. School & Ors.

Final Arguments (At 11:30 A.M.)


5. 01/2003 Sh. Karamvir V/s The Management of Gujrat Education Society & Ors.

6. 02/2003 Sh. Munna Lal V/s The Management of Gujrat Education Society & Ors.

7. 14/2004 Ms. Anju Farswan V/s Mayo International School & Ors.

8. 37/2004 Mrs. Neelam Gupta V/s Somerville School & Ors.

9. 18/2005 Ms. Neetu Parasher V/s Arun Modern Public Sec. School & ors.

10. 14/2006 Sh. Bakshish Singh V/s Guru Harkarishan Public School & Ors.

11. 29/2006 Sh. Manjeet Singh V/s State of NCT of Delhi & Ors.

12. 26/2007 Sh. Ganesh V/s Apex Public School & Ors.


Order (At 4.00 P.M.

13. 37/2002 Sh. Radhey Shyam Sharma V/s Chunni Lal Saraswati Bal Mandir & Ors.

Cause List 13-11-2007

BEFORE SHRI TALWANT SINGH: PRESIDING OFFICER
DELHI SCHOOL TRIBUNAL DELHI

13/11/2007


Misc. Proceedings (10.30 A.M)

1. 37/2007 Sh Sukhdev Jain V/s Modren School & Ors.

2. 44/2007 Smt Sunita Bugga V/s Director of Education & Ors.

Final Arguments (At 11:00 A.M.)


3. 37/1998 Sh Faqir Chand V/s Samarth Shiksha Samiti (Regd)
& Ors

4. 38/1998 Sh Vishwanath V/s Samarth Shiksha Samiti (Regd)
& Ors.

5. 05/2004 Ms Kusum Midha V/s Delhi Police Public School & Ors.

6. 04/2007 Ms Janet Vinita Jacob V/s Butla Memorial Girls Sr Sec School & Ors.

Order (At 4.00 P.M.

7. 04/2001 Ms Indu Bala V/s Guru Teg Bahadur Public School & Ors.

HAPPY DIWALI

HAPPY DIWALI TO ALL

Cause List 12-11-2007

BEFORE SHRI TALWANT SINGH: PRESIDING OFFICER
DELHI SCHOOL TRIBUNAL DELHI

12/11/2007


Misc. Arguments (11.00 A.M)

1. 33/2004 Mrs. Usha Shahi V/s The Management of Sophia’s Sr Sec School & Ors.

2. 34/1994 Sh Chander Parkash Gautam V/s Ramjas Sr Sec School & Ors.

Final Arguments (At 11:30 A.M.)


3. 14,20& Mrs Hoshiari Devi V/s Krishna Model Sec.
23/1997 School & Ors (3 Cases)

4. 14-16/2005 Mrs. Anita Bhandari V/s Director of Education & Ors. (3 Cases)

5. 30/2005 Mr Raj Kumar Sharma V/s Director of Education & Ors.

6. 13/2006 Ms Bazm Ara Begum V/s Director of Education & Ors.

Order (At 4.00 P.M.

7. 22/1999 Sh M K Aggarwal V/s Sadhu Vaswani School & Ors.

Meera Mishra Vs. Directorate of Education & Anr.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI

Date of Decision: 6th July, 2005

W.P. (C) No.5381/2002

Smt.Meera Mishra ...Petitioner

Versus

Directorate of Education & Anr. ...Respondents

VIKRAMAJIT SEN, J.

1.The Petitioner herein had earlier approached the Delhi School Tribunal in terms of Appeal No.47/1994 which was disposed of by Judgment dated 16.7.2002. Respondent No.2 herein was the first Respondent in those proceedings, and the principle of res judicata would squarely militate against it. The operative part of the Judgment reads as follows:

"The next relevant objection, raised by the Respondent No.1,is in para 3 of the written statement wherein they have stated that at no stage services of the Appellant had been terminated ever by the Respondent No.1 and by the Managing Committee of the Jain Shishu Niketan Primary School. The Appellant was still working as a Teacher in the same School. They have filed photostat copies of the documents like the Attendance Register and the Leave Applications given by the Appellant on 7.9.95.

In the rejoinder, the Appellant has stated that after she filed the appeal before this Tribunal, the Respondent No.1 agreed to withdraw the suspension and termination order, but up to date, the order has not been withdrawn. The Appellant has not been getting proper salary and she has not been given a rejoining letter. This reply of the Appellant shows that she has not specifically denied the fact that she is working in the School even at this time. There is nothing on record to show that her services were terminated by the School at any time. Under the circumstances, I find that the Appellant has no cause of action to file this appeal. The appeal is accordingly dismissed."

2. In view of the previous round of litigation, it is no longer possible for the Respondent School to contend that the Petitioner had not been employed by Jain Shiksha Samiti, Respondent No.2, which is recognized as well as financially aided by the Directorate of Education. Assuming that the Petitioner had been deputed to the Jain Shishu Niketan Primary School, a wing of Respondent No.2 running in its precincts, and stated to be a 'voluntary' effort, this factor alone would not defeat the claim of the Petitioner. Ms. Jain had attempted to convince me that the writ petition is not maintainable against Jain Shishu Niketan Primary School where the Petitioner was employed, but since this stance had not been adopted before the Delhi School Tribunal this contention stands foreclosed. Raising it at this belated stage leads me to view the Respondent School's defence as a chicanery, especially since it is now sought to be argued that the Petitioner has failed to report for duty at the Primary School.

3. Learned counsel for the Respondent School has belaboured the point that the Jain Shiksha Samiti is engaged in social service; that the Primary School does not receive aid from the State and Teachers render voluntary service. Assuming this to be true, it is indeed a contradiction in terms to compel a person to be a volunteer. What is distressing is that the Jain Shishu Niketan, run by the Jain Shiksha Samiti, is an aided School and yet it charges tuition fees from its students. In a retort to the litany and self-appreciation put forward on behalf of the Respondent School that it represents a philanthropic or charitable or social endeavour, a School Fees receipt had been handed over by learned counsel for the Petitioner in the course of arguments. Its genuineness has not been disputed and the only issue that has been pointed out by learned counsel for the Respondent School is that the receipt pertains to the Jain Shishu Niketan. The Samiti is expected to contribute five per cent of the total expenditure of the aided School but prima facie it appears that the Samiti may instead be making secret profits. This is impermissible, and the Directorate is directed to conduct a special audit into the affairs of the Jain Shishu Niketan as well as the so-called primary section and submit a Report to the Registrar General of this Court within ninety days from today.

4. As has already been observed, it is too late in the day for the Respondents School to make a distinction between the Jain Shishu Niketan and Jain Shishu Niketan Primary School. Since the Primary School is being run within the precincts of the aided school the distinction, if any, becomes blurred and indistinguishable. It has become commonplace for Societies, which are, receiving State aid, to conduct other financially remunerative activities the use of the proceeds of which are not known. In the present case assuming that school fees are being charged even though State aid is being received by the Samiti in respect of the Jain Shishu Niketan the overflow could easily be used for the unsupported endeavour of the primary school. This has obviously not happened.

5. The stand adopted by the Respondent before the Delhi School Tribunal was that the services of the Petitioner had not been terminated and it was on this ground that the Appeal was dismissed. If there is any truth in its present stance that the Petitioner has not reported for duty it ought to have instituted an enquiry. Admittedly this has not been done. In the hearing held on 21.4.2005 the Petitioner had offered to forgo all previous wages if she is given regular employment. The proceedings were adjourned to enable the Respondent School to consider the extremely fair and genuine offer. All that has been done is to delay further proceedings and re-argue the matter yet again.

6. The writ petition is allowed. The Respondent School is directed to release arrears of salary to the Petitioner with effect from 1.10.1995 within four weeks from today and thereafter pay her salaries by the 10th day of each calendar month. If the arrears of salary are not paid within four weeks from today the Respondent School shall be liable to pay interest thereon at the rate of 5 per cent per annum. The Petitioner has also prayed for a direction for assigning duties to her as a regular teacher. But if the Respondent chooses to waste its money by paying salaries to the Petitioner and yet not giving her any duties it is the Respondent School's concern. This Court need not pass any orders in that context. Since none of the contentions put forward on behalf of the Respondent School have any merit the Petitioner shall be entitled to costs of Rs.5,000/- which shall be paid to the Petitioner within four weeks from today.

7. The writ petition stands disposed of in the above terms.

Sd./-
VIKRAMAJIT SEN.J

Mrs.Florence Joel Vs. Mater Dei School & Ors.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI

CW.5446/2002.

Date of decision: August 20, 2004.

Mrs.Florence Joel ..... Petitioner

Through

Mr.S.K.Shukla, Advocate.

Versus

Mater Dei School & Ors. ......Respondents.

Through

Mr.M.Dias and

Mr.S.K.Shandilya, Advocates

for respondent Nos.1 and 2.

Mr.Aditya Madan, Advocate

for respondent No.3.

Manmohan Sarin, J(ORAL).

1. Rule.

With the consent of parties writ petition is taken up for disposal.

2. Petitioner, by this writ petition assails the order dated 17.7.2002, passed in appeal by the Delhi School Tribunal. Mr.Shukla, submits that petitioner was an illiterate widow, who had been engaged by Mater Dei School as a class IV employee. This was done in January, 1983. Her duties were washing clothes, cooking food, dusting and cleaning residential quarters of the Sisters and the chapel where the Sisters prayed. It is further claimed that petitioner was also cleaning the class rooms. Respondent-School and its Society did not issue any appointment letter to the petitioner. Petitioner's services were terminated vide letter dated 5.7.1996 w.e.f. 15.7.1996. It is stated that respondent Society, which ran the School paid a sum of Rs.13,288/- towards settlement of dues. Petitioner was not paid the regular salary and other retiral benefits, as paid to other employees. At the time of settlement, gratuity and compensation of 15 days each for every completed year of service was paid.

3. Respondents have filed the counter affidavit, denying the relationship of Employer and Employee between the Petitioner and School. It is stated that petitioner had approached the Sisters of the School, as she found herself in misery on account of ill-treatment by her husband, who was alleged to be a drunkard It is stated that purely as a humanitarian gesture, petitioner was given the job of cleaning, washing and attending to the cooking needs of the Sisters as also to clean the Chapel as part time domestic help. The Sisters, it is stated, are residing within the School premises. It is stated that the Sisters of the School had treated the petitioner as a member of the family and all her four children received free education and considerable financial assistance was given at the time of marriage of the daughters. Be that as it may, the question arising for consideration is whether petitioner was an employee of the School or not ?

4. Mr.Shukla submits that School is run by the Society. He places reliance on Municipal Corporation of Delhi Vs. Children Book Trust reported at 47 (1992) Delhi Law Times 424 SC to submit that the Society is to control the Managing Committee of the School and in this case the payments, which were made to the petitioner for settlement of dues, were made by the Society. He submits that as such relationship was established between the petitioner and the School. Petitioner was not the personal employee of the Sisters or Nuns. He also places reliance on Kapoor Chand & Ors. VS. Delhi Administration & Ors. reported at 1989 (16) D.R.J. 83. In this case, the conductors and drivers of the School bus were held to be employees of the School.

5. Mr.Shukla further in support of his contention stated that the School magazine is the mirror of the activities of the School and petitioner's photograph appears in the School magazine along with other members of the staff/employees. This amply showed that she was part of the family of the Mater Dei and her status was no different from that of regular employees.

6. I have heard Mr.M.Dias, in opposition. He has reiterated the contents of the counter affidavit, as filed and submits that this was not a case where the employer employee relationship between the Petitioner and School is at all established. There is no appointment letter issued to the petitioner, who is stated to have worked for over more than 13 years. Moreover, he submits that in none of the declarations/returns filed before the Directorate of Education, petitioner figured in the list of employees. He further explains that petitioner was part time domestic help. She was looking after the Sisters/Nuns. She used to clean and cook food for them. She was residing at Baba Kharak Singh Marg. The payments made to her were by the Society, since nuns having renounced the world, do not normally maintain any establishment. Their expenses and needs are all met by the Society. Hence the Society was providing them this facility of part time domestic help.

7. I have heard counsel for the parties and noted their contentions and have also perused the impugned order of the Delhi School Tribunal. I find that there is no infirmity in the order of the Delhi School Tribunal. Petitioner has failed to produce any appointment letter. It is not disputed that regular employees of the School were paid different scale and their names figure in the returns filed with the Directorate of Education and other statutory authorities. Petitioner did not figure in any of the staff list. The presence of photographs in school magazine shows that she was well treated and looked at as part of Mater Dei family. It does not make her an employee. The absence of the petitioner in any of the returns or staff list filed by the School with the Authorities as also the attendant circumstances negate the plea of being employee of School. The acceptance of salary of part time employee by her for all the 13 years without any reservation or protest does not lend any credibility to claim of being a regular employee of the School. I may notice that as a humanitarian gesture of help extended by the Society is sought to be used as a lever for asserting the claim of regular employment with the School. Not only this, the Society of the School while terminating the arrangement with the petitioner has taken care to provide her the amounts, which would be payable even for gratuity and compensation for each year of service.

8. In view of the foregoing discussion, there is no ground to interfere with the order passed by the Delhi School Tribunal. The writ petition is devoid of merit and is, accordingly, dismissed.

August 20, 2004 Manmohan Sarin, J.

Cause List 07-11-2007

BEFORE SHRI TALWANT SINGH: PRESIDING OFFICER
DELHI SCHOOL TRIBUNAL DELHI

07/11/2007

Misc. Proceedings (10.30 A.M)

1. 43/2007 Sh. Sain Singh & Ors. V/s Harcourt Butler Sr. Sec. School & Ors.

2. 27/2006 Mrs. Shikha Choudhary Srivastava V/s The Managing Committee, Joseklph & Mary School & Ors.

Misc. Arguments (11.00 A.M)

3. 25/2005 Mrs. Flowery Joseph V/s S.M. Arya Public School & Ors.

4. 04/2007 Ms. Janet Vinita Jacob V/s Butler Memorial School & Ors.

Final Arguments (At 11:30 A.M.)


5. 37/2002 Sh. Radhey Shyam Sharma V/s Chunni Lal Sarswati Bal Mandir & Ors.

6. 42/2003 Mrs. Prachi Gupta V/s Green Fields School & Ors.


7. 12/2000 Mrs. Gura Bhatnagar V/s Shri Guru Nanak Public School & Ors.

8. 7/2003 Ms Tapti Mitra V/s S.D. Public School & Ors.

Cause List 06-11-2007

BEFORE SHRI TALWANT SINGH: PRESIDING OFFICER
DELHI SCHOOL TRIBUNAL DELHI

06/11/2007

Misc. Proceedings (10.30 A.M)

1. 40/2007 : Sh Bansi Lal V/s Combridge Foundation S S School & Ors

2. 41/2007 : Sh Ram Kalap Tiwari V/s Combridge Foundation S S School & Ors

Misc. Arguments (11.00 A.M)


3. 15/2004 : Mrs Dimple Gupta V/s Suraj Kanya Shikhalaya & Ors.


Final Arguments (At 11:30 A.M.)



4. 06/2003 : Ms Neeta Kapoor V/s CRPF Public School & Ors.

5. 11/2003 : Ms Veena Garg V/s St. Sophia’s Sr Sec School & Ors.

6. 12/2003 : Ms Naresh Tomar V/s St. Sophia’s Sr Sec School & Ors.

7. 28/2004 : Sh V Mohan Rao V/s A E S Dr K R B M School & Ors.

8. 20/2005 : Ms Gurdeep Kaur V/s Mother Mary Public School & Ors.


Orders ( 4.00 P.M.)

9. 05/1996 : Archana Bains V/s Director of Education & Ors.

Cause List of 05/11/2007

BEFORE SHRI TALWANT SINGH: PRESIDING OFFICER
DELHI SCHOOL TRIBUNAL DELHI

5/11/2007


Misc. Proceedings (At 10:30 A.M.)

1. 33/2007 : Ms. Kusum Lata V/s NCT of Delhi & Ors.

2. 02/2007 : Ms Mala Mitra V/s The Managing Committee of Indian School & Ors.

3. 21/2007 : Sh. Rakesh Kumar V/s Govt. of NCT of Delhi & Ors

4. 34/2007 : Sh. Rakesh Kumar V/s Govt. of NCT of Delhi & Ors.

Misc. Arguments (11.00 A.M)

5. 17/2006 : Sh. Bhudev Prasad V/s Cambridge Primary School & Ors.


Final Arguments (At 11:30 A.M.)


6. 27/1997 : Smt. Lata Sharma V/s The Manager J.S.S. Khalsa School & Ors.

7. 38/1997 : Sh. C.L. Sethi V/s Director of Education & Ors.

8. 13/2001 : Sh. B.K. Paul V/s Bal Bharti School & Ors.

Cause List 2-11-2007

BEFORE SHRI TALWANT SINGH: PRESIDING OFFICER
DELHI SCHOOL TRIBUNAL DELHI

2/11/2007


Misc. Proceedings (At 10:30 A.M.)

1. 41/2007 (Contempt) : Sh. Ashok Kumar & Ors. V/s S.M. Arya Public School & Ors.

2. 10/2007 : Ms Amrita Kumari V/s Director of Education & Ors.

3. 13/2007 : Rekha Sabharwal V/s Saai Memorial School & Ors.


Misc. Arguments (11.00 A.M)

4. 6/1988 : Sh. Ramnath Sharma V/s Director of Education.


5. 12/2004 : Sh. Vinod Kumar V/s Principal S.Jassa Singh Ramgariha Public School & Ors.

Final Arguments (At 11:30 A.M.)


6. 34/2004 : Sh. Raghubir Singh V/s Hope Hall Foundation School & Ors.

7. 5/1999 : Sh. Mahinder Kumar Sharma V/s The Management of Green Field School & Ors.

8. 11/2000 : Sh. Raj Pal Singh V/s The Managing Committee , St. Paul’s School & Ors.

9. 38/2001 : Sh. S.P.Sharma V/s The Managing Committee St. Lawrence Convent School & Ors.

10. 13/2002 : Sh. Shiv Kumar Sharma V/s St. Columbas School & Ors.

11. 22/2002 : Smt. Sunita Rana V/s Vidya Jyoti Public School & Ors.

12. 23/2002 : Smt. Saroj Bala V/s Vidya Jyoti Public School & Ors.

Cause List for 01-11-2007

BEFORE MR. TALWANT SINGH
PRESIDING OFFICER
DELHI SCHOOL TRIBUNAL

1/11/2007

Misc. Proceedings (At 10:30 A.M.)

1. 47/2007 : Smt. Pooja Kapoor V/s The Managing Committee Saviour Convent Sr, Sec. School & Ors.

2. 05/2007 : Achint Kumar Ganguli V/s The Mamta Modern Education Society & Ors.

3. 46/2007 : Achint Kumar Ganguli V/s Mamta Modern Education Society & Ors.

4. 25/2007 : Smt. Mridul Sharma V/s Director of Education. & Ors.

Final Arguments (At 11:30 A.M.)

5. 12/1002 : Sh. Paras Nath Sharma V/s Delhi Public School & Ors.

6. 1/2002 : Sh. Bir Singh V/s Delhi Public School & Ors.

7. 3/1991 : Mrs. Usha Rani V/s Director of Education. & Ors.

8. 63/2002 : Mrs. Vandana V/s The Management , Remal Public School & ors.

9. 05/2003 : Mrs. Shayamashri Majumdar V/s Remal Public Sr. School & Ors.
.

Cause LIst 31-10-2007

BEFORE SHRI TALWANT SINGH: PRESIDING OFFICER
DELHI SCHOOL TRIBUNAL DELHI

31/10/2007


Misc. Proceedings (At 10:30 A.M.)

1. 35/2007 : Ms. Preeti Sodhi V/s Apeejay School & Ors.

Misc. Arguments (At 11:00 A.M.)

2. 30/2007 : Mrs. Gurpiari V/s Vansthali Public School & Ors.

3. 09/1999 : Mrs. Anjana Samnol V/s Apeejay School & Ors.

4. 15/1997 : Sh. Chatter Singh V/s Hansraj Model School & Ors.

5. 20/2004 : Ms Raj Gakhar V/s D A V Managing Committee Shaf & Ors.


Final Arguments (At 11:30 A.M.)

6. 25/1994 : Mrs. Veena Joshi V/s Managing Committee S D Public School & Ors.

7. 15/1999 : Smt. Poonam Vig V/s Sadhu Vaswani International School & Ors.

8. 22/1999 : Sh M K Aggarwal V/s Sadhu9 Vaswani International School & Ors.

9. 07/2004 : Sh. Rohtas Singh V/s Director of Education & Ors.

10. 26/2001 : Sh Dharmender Arora V/s Bal Bharati Public School & Ors.

11. 36/2003 : Sh. J S Chouhan V/s Bal Bharati Public School & Ors

Orders (At 4.00 P.M.)

12. 07/1997 : Mrs Suman Sharma V/s Gramin Sikshan Sanstha & Ors.

13. 08/1997 : Sh Yug Raj V/s Gramin Sikshan Sanstha & Ors.

14. 04/2001 : Ms Indu Bala V/s Guru Teg Bahadur Public School & Ors.

15. 03/2004 : Ms Rakhi Arora V/s D A V Cetenary Public School & Ors.

Cause List for 30/10/2007

BEFORE MR. TALWANT SINGH
PRESIDING OFFICER
DELHI SCHOOL TRIBUNAL
DELHI-110054

Misc. Proceedings (At 10:30 A.M.)

1. 40/2003: Ms. Indira Sharma V/s Heera Public School & Ors.

2. 18/2007 : Ms. Bharti Shounak V/s Director of Education & Ors.

3. 19/2007 : Smt. Rashi Sekhri V/s Director of Education & Ors.

4. 19/2006 : Mrs. Anita Saini V/s Director of Education & Ors.

5. 32/2006 : Smt. Kamal Saini V/s Director of Education & Ors.

Misc. Arguments (At 11:00 A.M.)

6. 20/1998 : Mrs. Priti Madan V/s Sumermal Jain Public School & Ors.

7. 24/2005 : Mrs. Manisha Sood V/s Bal Bharti Public School & Ors.

8. 21/2006 : Sh. Rajinder Goyal V/s Hansraj Model School & Ors.

9. 03/2007 : Sh. Arshad Mujib Ansari V/s Managing Committee Shafiq Memorial Sr. Sec. School & Ors.

10. 24/2007 : Smt. Ravinder Kaur Datta V/s Guru Nanak Public School & Ors.

Final Arguments (At 11:30 A.M.)

11. 08/1999 : Sh. Rakesh Chopra V/s Director of Education & Ors.

12. 25/2000 : Sh. Anirudh Kumar Pandey V/s Modern Public School & Ors.

13. 66/2002 : Mrs. Neeta Datta V/s Arwachin Bharti Bhawan Sr. Sec. School & Ors.

14. 45/2003 : Sh. Dipak Chandra V/s Savti Devi Memorial Sr. Sec. Vidya Mandir & Ors.

15. 28/2005 : Smt. Vijoya Chatterjee V/s Guru Angad Public School & Ors.

Final Arguments (At 2:00 P.M.)

16. 17/2002 : Sh. Raj Kumar V/s Delhi Jain Public School & Ors (four Cases)

Daily Cause Lists on Blog

We will make sincere efforts to ensure that the cause lists are uploaded one day in advance on our blog.

Cause List for 29/10/2007

BEFORE MR. TALWANT SINGH
PO: DELHI SCHOOL TRIBUNAL

Misc. Proceedings (At 10:30 A.M.)

1. 18/2004 : Ms Shashi Chawla V/s S M Arya Public School & Ors.

Misc. Arguments (At 11:00 A.M.)

2. 3/2004 : Ms Rakhi Arora V/s D A V Cetenary Public School & Ors.

3. 17/2004 : Mrs. Khima Devi V/s Ravindra Memorial Public School & Others

4. 39/2007 : The Managing Committee of Rattan Devi Arya G S S School & Ors.

Final Arguments (At 11:30 A.M.)

5. 15/2000 : Sh Kushal Singh V/s Mont Fort Sr. Sec. School & Ors.

6. 04/2002 : Sh. Jagdish Kumar & Orthers V/s Amar Public School & Ors. (6 Cases)

7. 11/2006 : Mrs Anupama Arora V/s S M Arya Public School & Ors.

Orders (4.00 P.M)

8. 10/1979 : Sh. Sri Niwas V/s D C M Cloth Mills Sr Sec School & Ors.

9. 12/1998 : Mrs Rita Saklani V/s S M Arya Public School & Ors.

10. 34/2007 : Sh Rakesh Kumar V/s Director of Education & Ors.

Delhi School Education Act, 1973

The Delhi School Education Act, 1973
(Act No. 18 of 1973)
[9th April, 1973]

An Act to provide for better organisation and development of school education in the Union Territory of Delhi and for matters connected therewith or incidental thereto.

Be it enacted by Parliament in the Twenty-fourth Year of the Republic of India as follows:

CHAPTER I
PRELIMINARY

1. Short title, extent and commencement- (1) This Act may be called the Delhi School Education Act, 1973.
(2) It extends to the whole of the Union territory of Delhi.
(3) It shall come into force on such date as the Administrator may, by notification, appoint and different dates may be appointed for different provisions of this Act, and any reference to the commencement of this Act in relation to any provision thereof shall be construed as a reference to the date on which that provision comes into force.

2. Definitions- In this Act, unless the context otherwise requires:-
a) "Administrator" means the Administrator of the Union Territory of Delhi appointed by the President under article 239 of the Constitution;
b) "Advisory Board" means the Board referred to in section 22;
c) "Aid" means any aid granted to a recognised school by the Central Government, Administrator, a local authority or any other authority designated by the Central Government, Administrator of a. local authority;
d) "Aided School" means a recognized private school which is receiving aid in the form of maintenance grant from the Central Government, Administrator or a local authority or any other authority designated by the Central Government Administrator or a local authority;
e) "appropriate authority" means :-
i. in the case of a school recognised or to be recognised by an authority designated or sponsored by the Central Government, that authority;
ii. in the case of a school recognised or to be recognised by the Delhi Administration, the Administrator or any other officer authorised by him in this behalf;
iii. in the case: of a school recognised or to be recognised Municipal Corporation of Delhi, that Corporation;
iv. in the case of any other school, the Administrator or any other officer authorized by him in this behalf;
f) "Delhi" means the Union Territory of Delhi;
g) "Director" means; the Director of Education, Delhi, and includes any other officer authorised by him to perform all or any of the functions of the Director under the act;
h) "employee" means a teacher and includes every other employee working in a recognized school;
i) “existing employee” means an employee of an existing school who is employed in
such school immediately be fore the commencement of this Act, and includes an employee who was employed in such school for a period of not less than twelve months immediately preceding the 2nd day of September, 1972.
j) "existing school" means a recognised private school which is in existence at the commencement of this Act;
k) "Head of school" means the principal academic officer, by whatever name called, of a recognised school;
l) "Local authority" means,-
i. in relation to an area Within the local limits of the Municipal Corporation of Delhi, that Corporation;
ii. in relation to an area within the local limits of the New Municipal Committee, that Committee;
iii. in relation to an area within the local limits of the Delhi Cantonment Board, that Board;
m) "manager" in relation to a school, means the person, by whatever name called, who
is entrusted, either on the date on which this Act comes into force or, as the case may be, under a scheme of management made under section 5, with the management of the affairs of that school;
n) "managing committee" means the body of individuals who are entrusted with the management of any recognised private school;
o) "minority school" means a school established and administer, a minority having the right to do so under clause (1) of article the Constitution;
p) "notification" means a notification published in the Official Gazette;
q) "prescribed" means prescribed by rules made under this Act;
r) "private school" means a school which is not run by the Central Government, Administrator, a local authority or any other authority designated or sponsored by the Central Government Administrator or a local authority;
s) public examination" means an examination conducted by the Central Board of Secondary Education, Council for Indian School Certificate Examinations or any other Board which may hereafter be established for the purpose, and recognised by the Administrator or any other officer authorised by him in this behalf;
t) "recognised school" means a school recognised by the appropriate authority;
u) "school" includes a pre-primary, primary, middle and higher secondary school, and also includes any other institution which imparts education or training below the degree level, but does-not include an institution which imparts technical education;
v) "school property" means all moveable and immovable property belonging to, or in the possession of, the school and all other rights and interests in, or arising out of, such property, and includes land, building and its appurtenances, playgrounds, hostels, furniture, books, apparatus, maps, equipment, utensils, cash, reserve funds, investments and bank balances;
w) "teacher" includes the Head of school;
x) "unaided minority school" means a recognised minority school which does not receive any aid.

CHAPTER II
ESTABLISHMENT, RECOGNITION, MANAGEMENT OF, AND AID TO SCHOOLS

3. Power of Administrator to Regulate Education in Schools- (1) The Administrator may regulate education in all the schools in Delhi in accordance with the provisions of this Act and the rules made thereunder.
(2) The Administrator may establish and maintain any school in Delhi may permit any person or local authority to establish and maintain any school ill Delhi, subject to compliance with the provisions of this Act and the rules made thereunder.
(3) On and from the commencement of this Act and subject to the provisions of clause (1) of Article 30 of the Constitution, the establishment of a new school or the opening of a higher class or the closing down of an existing class in any existing school in Delhi shall be subject to the provisions of this Act and the rules made thereunder and any school or higher class established or opened than in accordance with the provisions of this Act shall not be recognised by the appropriate authority.

(4) Recognition of schools- (1) The appropriate authority may on application made to it in the prescribed form and in the prescribed manner, recognise any private school:
Provided that no school shall be recognised unless-
a) it has adequate funds to ensure its financial stability and payment of salary and allowances to its employees;
b) it has a duly approved scheme of management as required by section 5
c) it has suitable or adequate accommodation and sanitary facilities having regard, among other factors, to the number, age and sex of the pupils attending it;
d) it provides for approved courses of study and efficient instruction
e) it has teachers with prescribed qualifications; and
f) it has the prescribed facilities for physical education, library service, laboratory work, workshop practice or co-curricular activities.
(2) Every application for recognition of a school shall be entertained and considered by the appropriate authority and the decision thereon shall be communicated to the applicant within a period of four months from the date of receipt of the application; and where recognition is not granted, the reasons for not granting such recognition shall also be communicated to the applicant with the said period.
(3) Where recognition to a school is refused, any person aggrieved by such refusal may, within thirty days from the date of communication to him, of such refusal, appeal against such refusal, in the prescribed manner, to the prescribed authority and the decision of the prescribed authority thereon shall be final :
Provided that the prescribed authority may, if it is satisfied that the appellant was prevented by sufficient cause from preferring the appeal within the said period of thirty days, extend, for reasons to be recorded by it in writing, the said period by a further period of sixty days.
(4) Where the managing committee of a school obtains recognition by fraud, misrepresentation or suppression of material particulars, or where, after obtaining recognition, the school fails to continue to comply with any of the conditions specified in the proviso to sub-section (1), the authority granting the recognition may, after giving the managing committee of the school a reasonable opportunity of showing cause against the proposed action, withdraw the recognition granted to such school under sub-section (1).
(5) The recognition granted under sub-section (1) shall not, by itself, entitle any school to receive aid.
(6) Every existing school shall be deemed to have been recognised under this section and shall be subject to the provisions of this Act and the rules made thereunder:
Provided that where any such school does not satisfy any of the conditions specified in the proviso to sub-section (1), the prescribed authority may require, the school to satisfy such conditions and such other conditions as may be prescribed, within a specified period and if any such condition is not satisfied, recognition may be withdrawn from such school.
(7) Every school, whose recognition is withdrawn under sub-section (4) or sub-section (6), may appeal to the prescribed authority, who shall dispose of the appeal Within six months from the date of presentation of the appeal in such manner as may be prescribed, and if the appeal is not disposed of within that period, the order for the withdrawal of recognition shall, on the expiry of the said period of six months, stand cancelled.
(8) On hearing an appeal preferred under sub-section (3) or sub-section (7), the prescribed authority may, after giving the appellant a reasonable opportunity of being heard, confirm, modify or reverse an order appealed against.

5. Scheme of management- (1) Notwithstanding anything contained in any other law for the time being in force or in any instrument having effect by virtue of any such law, the managing committee of every recognised school shall make, in accordance with the rules made under this Act and with the previous approval of the appropriate authority, a scheme of management for such school:
Provided that in the case of a recognised private school which does not " receive any aid, the scheme of management shall apply with such variations and modifications as may be prescribed:
Provided further that so much of this sub-section as relates to the previous approval of the appropriate authority, shall not apply to a scheme of management for an unaided minority school.
(2) a scheme may be made, in like manner, to add, to vary or modify any scheme made under sub-section (1).

6. Aid to recognised schools - (1) The Central Government may, after the due appropriation made by Parliament by law in this behalf and subject to such conditions as may be prescribed, pay to the Administrator, for distribution of aid to recognised private schools, not being primary schools recognised by a local authority, such sums of money as that Government may consider necessary:
Provided that no existing school receiving, immediately before the commencement of this Act, aid shall be eligible for the continuance of such aid unless it complies, within such period as may be specified by the Director, with the conditions specified in the proviso to sub-section (1) of section 4.
(2) The authority competent to grant the aid may stop, reduce or suspend aid for violation of any of the conditions prescribed in this behalf.
(3) The aid may cover such part of the expenditure of the school as prescribed.
(4) No payment, out of the aid given for salary, allowances and pro fund of employees of the school, shall be made for any other purpose.
(5) No aid shall be given to a school the management of which has taken over under section 20.
(6) No unrecognised school shall be eligible to receive any aid or any benefit made available to private schools by the Administrator or any agency of the Administrator.


CHAPTER III
SCHOOL PROPERTY

7. School Property- (1) The management of every aided school shall furnish to the appropriate authority, initially, at the time of grant of aid and thereafter annually, a statement containing a list of school property together, such particulars as may be prescribed.
(2) Notwithstanding anything contained in any other law for the time being in force, no transfer, mortgage or lease of any movable immovable property of an aided school, not being the property specified in the rules, shall be made except with the previous permission of the appropriate authority:
Provided that where the appropriate authority omits or fails to dispose of the application for such permission within sixty days from the date of receipt of the application in this behalf, the permission shall, on the expiry of the said period of sixty days, be deemed to have been granted.
(3) Any person aggrieved by the grant or refusal of permission under sub-section (2) may prefer, in such form and within such time as may be prescribed, appeal to the Administrator against such grant or refusal of permission and the decision of the Administrator thereon shall be final.
(4) Any transaction made in contravention of the provisions of sub-section (3), or as the case may be, decision of the Administrator, shall be void.


CHAPTER IV
TERMS AND CONDITIONS OF SERVICE OF EMPLOYEES OF RECOGNISED PRIVATE SCHOOLS

8. Terms and conditions of service of employees of recognised private schools- (1) The Administrator may make rules regulating the minimum qualifications for recruitment, and the conditions of service, of employees of recognized private schools:
Provided that neither the salary nor the rights in respect of leave of absence, age of retirement and pension of an employee in the employment of an existing school at the commencement of this Act shall be varied to the disadvantage of such employee:
Provided further that every such employee shall be entitled to opt for terms and conditions of service as they were applicable to him immediately before the commencement of this Act.
(2) Subject to any rule that may be made in this behalf, no employee of a recognised private school shall be dismissed, removed or reduced in rank nor shall his service be otherwise terminated except with the prior approval of the Director.
(3) Any employee of a recognised private school who is dismissed, removed or reduced in rank may, within three months from the date of communication to him of the order of such dismissal, removal or reduction in rank, appeal against such order to the Tribunal constituted under section 11.
(4) Where the managing committee of a recognised private school intends to suspend any of its employees, such intention shall be communicated to the Director and no such suspension shall be made except with the prior approval of the Director:
Provided that the managing committee may suspend an employee with immediate effect and without the prior approval of the Director if it is satisfied that such immediate suspension is necessary by reason of the gross misconduct within the meaning of the Code of Conduct prescribed under section 9, of the employee:
Provided further that no such immediate suspension shall remain in force for more than a period of fifteen days from the date of suspension unless it has been communicated to the Director and approved by him before the expiry of the said period.
(5) Where the intention to suspend or the immediate suspension of an employee is communicated to the Director, he may, if he is satisfied that there are adequate and reasonable grounds for such suspension, accord his approval to such suspension.

9. Employees to be governed by a Code of Conduct- Every employee of a recognised school shall be governed by such Code of Conduct as may be prescribed and on the violation of any provision of such Code of Conduct, the employee shall be liable to such disciplinary action as may be prescribed.

10. Salaries of employees- (1) The scales of pay and allowances, medical facilities, pension, gratuity, provident fund and other prescribed benefits of the employees of a recognised private school shall not be less than those of the employees of the corresponding status in school run by the appropriate authority:
Provided that where the scales of pay and allowances, medical facilities, pension, gratuity, provident fund and other prescribed benefits of the employees of any recognised private school are less than those of the employees of the corresponding status in the schools run by the appropriate authority, the appropriate authority shall direct, in writing, the managing committee of such bring the same up to the level of those of the employees of the corresponding status in schools run by the appropriate authority:
Provided further that the failure to comply with such direction deemed to be non-compliance with the conditions for continuing recognition of an existing school and the provisions of section 4 shall apply accordingly.
(2) The managing committee of every aided school shall deposit month, every month, its share towards pay and allowances, medical facilities, pension, gratuity, provident fund and other prescribed benefits with the Administrator and the Administrator shall disburse, or cause to be disbursed, within the first week of every month, the salaries and allowances to the employees of the aided schools.

11. Tribunal- (1) The Administrator shall, by notification, constitute a Tribunal, to be known as the "Delhi School Tribunal", consisting of one person:
Provided that no person shall be so appointed unless he has held office as a District Judge or any equivalent judicial office.
(2) If any vacancy, other than a temporary absence, occurs in the office presiding officer of the Tribunal, the Administrator shall appoint another person, in accordance with the provisions of this section, to fill the vacancy ant proceedings may be continued before the Tribunal from the stage at which vacancy is filled.
(3) The Administrator shall make available to the Tribunal such staff as! be necessary in the discharge of its functions under this Act.
4) All expenses incurred in connection with the Tribunal shall be defrayed out of the
Consolidated Fund of India.
(5) The Tribunal shall have power to regulate its own procedure in all matters arising out of the discharge of its functions including the place or places at which it shall hold its sitting.
(6) The Tribunal shall for the purpose of disposal of an appeal preferred under this Act have the same powers as are vested in a court of appeal by the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, (5 of 1908) and shall also have the power to stay the operation of the order appealed against on such terms as it may think fit.

12. Chapter not to apply to unaided minority schools- Nothing contained, in this Chapter shall apply to an unaided minority school.


CHAPTER V
PROVISIONS APPLICABLE TO UNAIDED MINORITY SCHOOLS

13. Power to prescribe minimum qualifications for recruitment- The Administrator may make rules regulating the minimum qualifications for, and method of, recruitment of employees of unaided minority schools:
Provided that no qualification shall be varied to the disadvantage of an to existing employees of an unaided minority school.

14. Power to prescribe Code of Conduct- Every employee of an unaided minority school shall be governed by such Code of Conduct as may be prescribed.

15. Contract of service- (1) The managing committee of every unaided minority school shall enter into a written contract of service with every employee of such school:
Provided that if, at the commencement of this Act, there is no written contract of service in relation to any existing employee of an unaided minority school, the managing committee of such school shall enter into such contract within a period of three months from such commencement:
Provided further that no contract referred to in the foregoing proviso shall vary to the disadvantage of any existing employee the term of any contract subsisting at the commencement of this Act between him and the school.
(2) A copy of every contract of service referred to in sub-section (1) shall be forwarded by the managing committee of the concerned unaided minority school to the Administrator who shall, on receipt of such copy, register it in such manner as may be prescribed.
(3) Every contract of service referred to in sub-section (1) shall provide for the following matters, namely:
a) the terms and conditions of service of the employee, including the scale of pay and other allowances to which he shall be entitled ;
b) the leave of absence, age of retirement, pension and gratuity, or, contributory provident fund in lieu of pension and gratuity, and medical and other benefits to which the employee shall be entitled;
c) the penalties which may be imposed on the employee for the violation of any Code of Conduct or the breach of any term of the contract entered into by him;
d) the manner in which disciplinary proceedings in relation to the employee shall be conducted and the procedure which shall be followed before any employee is dismissed, removed from service or reduced in rank;
e) arbitration of any dispute arising out of any breach of contract between the employee and the managing committee with regard to the scales of pay and other allowances,
ii leave of absence, age of retirement, pension, gratuity, provident fund, medical and other benefits,
iii any disciplinary action leading to the dismissal or removal from service or reduction in rank of the employee;
f) any other matter which, in the opinion of the managing committee, ought to be, or may be, specified in such contract.


CHAPTER VI
ADMISSION TO SCHOOLS AND FEES

16. Admission to recognised schools- (1) A child who has not attained age of five years, shall not be admitted to class I, or an equivalent class or any class higher than class I, in a recognised school.
(2) A student seeking admission for the first time in a recognised school in a class higher than class I shall not be admitted to that class if his age reduced by the number of years of normal school study between that class and class I or an equivalent class, falls short of five years.
(3) Admission to a recognised school or to any class thereof shall be regulated by rules made in this behalf.

17. Fees and other charges- (1) No aided school shall levy fee or collect any other charge or receive any other payment except those specified by the Director.
(2) Every aided school having different rates of fees or other charges or different funds shall obtain prior approval of the prescribed authority before levying such fees or collecting such charges or creating such funds.
(3) The manager of every recognised school, shall before the commencement of each academic session, file with the Director a full statement of the fees to be levied by such school during the ensuing academic session, and except wit the prior approval of the Director, no such school shall charge, during that academic session, any fee in excess of the fee specified by its manager in the said statement.

18. School Fund- (1) In every aided school, there shall be a fund, to be called the "School Fund" and there shall be credited thereto-
(a) any aid granted by the Administrator,
(b) income accruing to the school by way of fees, charges or other payments, and (c) any other contributions, endowments and the like.
(2) The School Fund and all other fund, including the Pupils' Funds, established with the approval of the Administrator, shall be accounted for and operated in accordance with the rules made under this Act.
(3) In every recognised unaided school, there shall be a fund, to be called the "Recognised Unaided School Fund", and there shall be credited thereto income accruing to the school by way of
a) fees,
b) any charges and payments which may be realised by the school for other specific purposes, and
c) any other contributions, endowments, gifts and the like.
(4) (a) Income derived by unaided schools by way of fees shall be utilized only for such educational purposes as may be prescribed; and
(b) Charges and payments realised and all other contributions, endowments and gifts received by the school shall be utilised only for the specific purpose for which they were realised or received.
(5) The managing committee of every recognised private school shall file every year with the Director such duly audited financial and other returns as may be prescribed, and every such return shall be audited by such authority as may be prescribed.

19. Affiliations- (1) For the purpose of any public examination every recognised higher secondary school shall be affiliated to one or more of the Boards or Council conducting such examination and shall fulfill the conditions specified by the Board or Council in this behalf.
(2) The students of recognised higher secondary schools shall be prepared for, and presented to, the public examinations or such other form of evaluation held or made for the students of such schools.
(3) The students of every recognised middle school shall be prepared for, and presented to, such public examination as may be held by the Directorate of Education, Delhi, for the students of such schools.
(4) Every student of a recognised primary school shall be prepared for, and presented to, the public examination held by a local authority competent to hold such examination for the students of such schools.


CHAPTER VII
TAKING OVER THE MANAGEMENT OF SCHOOL

20. Taking over the management of schools- (1) Whenever the Administrator is satisfied that the managing committee or manager of any school, whether recognised or not, has neglected to perform any of the duties imposed on it by or under this Act or any rule made thereunder and that it is expedient in the interests of school education to take over the management of such school, he may, after giving the managing committee or the manager of such school, a reasonable opportunity of showing cause against the proposed action, take over the management of such school for a limited period not exceeding three years :
Provided that where the management of a school has been taken over for a period of three years or less, the Administrator may, if he is of opinion that in order to secure proper management of the school it is expedient that such management should continue to be in force after the expiry of the said limited period, he may, from time to time, issue directions for the continuance management of such management for such period not exceeding one year at a time as he may think fit, so however, that the total period for which such management is taken over shall not, in any case, exceed five years.
(2) Whenever the management of any school is taken over under sub-section (I), every person in charge of the management of such school immediately before its management is taken over, shall deliver possession of the school property to the Administrator or any officer authorised by him in this behalf.
(3) After taking over the management of any school under this section, the Administrator may arrange to manage the school through the Director or any other person authorised by the Director in this behalf (hereinafter referred to as the "authorised officer").
(4) Where the management of any school has been taken over under sub-section (1), the managing committee or manager of such school may, within three months from the date of taking over, appeal to the Administrator, who may after considering the representation made by the managing committee or the manager, pass such orders, including an order for the restorations of the management or for the reduction of the period during which the management of such school small remain vested in the Administrator, as he may deem fit.
(5) Where the management of a school has been taken over under section, the Administrator shall be pay such rent as may be payable for building of the school to the person entitled to receive it as was being paid by managing committee or the manager immediately before the management such school was taken over.
(6) During such period as any school remains under the management of authorised officer:
a) the service conditions, as approved by the Administrator, of employees of the school who were in employment immediately before the date on which the management was taken over, shall not be varied to their disadvantage;
b) all educational facilities which the school had been affording immediately before such management was taken over, shall continue be afforded;
c) the School Fund, the Pupils' Fund and the Management Fund and any other existing fund shall continue to be available to the authorised officer for being spent for the purposes of the school; and
d) no resolution passed as any meeting of the managing committee of such school shall be given effect to unless approved by the Administrator.

21. Section 20 not to apply to minority schools- Nothing contained in section 20 shall apply to any minority school.


CHAPTER VIII
MISCELLANEOUS

22. Delhi Schools Education Advisory Board- (1) There shall be an Advisory Board for school education, to be called the "Delhi School Education Advisory Board" for the purpose of advising the Administrator on matters of policy relating the education in Delhi.
(2) The Advisory Board shall be constituted by the Administrator and shall consist of a Chairman and fourteen other members, to be nominated by the Administrator.
(3) The Advisory Board constituted under sub-section (2) shall include
a) Heads of recognised private schools;
b) representatives of the organisations of teachers of the recognized private schools;
c) managers of the recognised private schools;
d) representatives of parents or guardians of students of recognized private schools; and
e) eminent educationists.
(4) The Advisory Board shall regulate its own procedure.
(5) The terms of office of every member of the Board and travelling and other, allowances payable to a member of the Board shall be such as may be prescribed.

23. Delegation of powers- (1) The Administrator may delegate all or any of his powers, duties and functions under this Act to the Director or any other officer.
(2) Every person to whom any power is delegated under sub-section (1), may exercise that power in the same manner and with the same effect as if such power had been conferred on him directly by this Act a and not by way of delegation.

24. Inspection of schools- (1) Every recognised school shall be inspected t least once in each financial year in such manner as may be prescribed.
(2) The Director may also arrange special inspection of any school on such aspects of its working as may, from time to time, be considered necessary by him.
(3) The Director may give directions to the manager requiring the manager to rectify any defect or deficiency found at the time of inspection or otherwise in the working of the school.
(4) If the manager fails to comply with any direction given under sub- section (3), the Director may, after considering the explanation or report, if any, given or made by the manager, take such action as he may think fit, including-
(a) stoppage of aid,
(b) withdrawal of recognition, or
(c) except in the case of a minority school, taking over of the school under section 20.

25. Jurisdiction of civil Courts barred- No civil Court shall have jurisdiction in respect of any matter in relation to which the Administrator or the Director or any other person authorised by the Administrator or Director or any other officer or authority appointed or specified by or under this Act, is empowered by or under this Act to exercise any power, and no injunction shall be granted by any civil court in respect of anything which is done or intended to be done by or under this Act.

26. Protection of action taken in good faith- No suit, prosecution or other legal proceeding shall lie against the Administrator, Director or any other person authorised by the Administrator or Director for anything which is in good faith done or intended to be done in pursuance of this Act or any rule made thereunder.

27. Liability of manager to punishment- If the manager of any recognised private school –
a) omits or fails, without any reasonable excuse, too carry a orders made by the Tribunal, or
b) presents any student for any public examination without complying with the provisions of section 19, or
c) omits or fails to deliver any school property to the Administrator or any officer authorised by him under sub-section (2) of section 20, he shall be punished with imprisonment for a term which may extend to three months, or with fine which may extent to one thousand rupees, or with both.

28. Power to make ru]es- (1) The Administrator may, with the previous approval of the Central Government, and subject to the condition of previous publication, by notification, make rules to carry out the provisions of this act.
(2) In particular, and without prejudice to the generality of the foregoing power, such rules may provide for all or any of the following matters, namely:-
a) the manner in which education may be regulated by the Administrator in Delhi;
b) the conditions which every existing school shall be required to comply;
c) establishment of a new school or the opening of a higher class or the closing down of an existing class in an existing school;
d) the form and manner in which an application for recognition school shall be made;
e) the facilities to be provided by a school to obtain recognition;
f) the manner in which, and the authority to which, an appeal against the refusal or withdrawal of recognition shall be made;
g) the minimum qualifications for, and method of recruitment, and the terms and conditions of service of employees;
h) the authorities to be specified for the purposes of the different provisions of this Act;
i) the particulars which a scheme of management shall contain and the manner in which such scheme shall be made;
j) variations and modifications which may be made in the scheme of management for a recognised school which does not receive any aid
k) the conditions under which aid may be granted to recognised schools, and on the
violation of which aid may be stopped, reduced or suspended;
l) the part of the expenditure of a recognised school which is to be covered by aid;
m) particulars of school property which should be furnished to the appropriate authority;
n) the form in which, and the time within which, an appeal shall be preferred to the Administrator against an order made in relation to the transfer, mortgage or lien of any school property;
o) the Code of Conduct for the employees and disciplinary action to be taken for the violation thereof;
p) the benefits which should be granted to the employees of recognised private schools;
q) admissions to a recognised school;
r) fees and other charges which may be collected by an aided school;
s) the manner of inspection of recognised schools
t) the terms of office, traveling and other allowances payable to the members of the Advisory Board;
u) financial and other returns to be filed by the managing committee of recognised private schools, and the authority by which such returns shall be audited;
v) educational purposes for which the income derived by way of fees by recognised unaided schools shall be spent;
w) manner of accounting and operation of school funds and other funds of a recognised private school;
x) fees; not exceeding one rupee, for preferring any appeal under this Act;
y) any other matter which is to be, or may be, prescribed under this Act.
(3) Every rule made under this Act shall be laid, as soon as may be is made, before each House of Parliament while it is in session for a total period of thirty days which may be comprised in one session or in two or more successive sessions, and if, before the expiry of the session immediately following the session or the successive sessions aforesaid, both Houses agree in making any modification in the rule or both Houses agree that the rule should not be made, the rule shall thereafter have effect only in such modified form or be of no effect, as the case may be; so, however, that any such modification or annulment shall be without prejudice to the validity of anything previously done under that rule.

29. Power to remove difficulties- If any difficulty arises in giving effect to the provisions of this Act, the Central Government may, by order not inconsistent with the provisions of this Act, remove the difficulty.